Italian Takeout in Sarasota - Order Online, Ready in 25 Minutes
Handmade pasta, whole-tray focaccia and antipasti, packed hot and ready fast at 3105 N Tamiami Trl. No apps, no fees, no soggy delivery bags - just real Italian to go.
Three steps to dinner on your table.
1. Order online
Pick from 35+ dishes on our pickup menu - pasta, focaccia, mains, salads, sides. Pay by card, done in a minute.
2. We cook it fresh
Nothing sits under a heat lamp. Your order hits the kitchen the moment you pay and is ready in about 25 minutes.
3. Swing by & go
Free parking right at the door, 3105 N Tamiami Trl. We call you when it's ready - grab it and go. Open Mon-Sat 4-9 PM, Sun 12-9 PM.
Why Sarasota picks up from My Mamma.
No delivery-app markup
Ordering direct means menu prices, not app prices - no service fees, no surge, no cold food after 50 minutes in a car. You save 20-30% versus delivery apps.
2-for-1 pasta special
Takeaway-only promo: Spaghetti & Polpette, two full portions for the price of one. Claim the 2-for-1.
Built to travel
Lasagna, parmigiana and baked pasta reheat beautifully; focaccia trays feed 4-6. We pack sauces smart so nothing arrives sad.
Feeding a crowd? We deliver that.
For 10-500 guests our catering is delivered hot across Sarasota and Bradenton ($50 flat) - office lunches, parties, weddings, from $24 per person.
Most-ordered takeout tonight
Spaghetti & Polpette - $23.90
Grandma's meatballs in slow San Marzano ragù. On the 2-for-1 promo, it feeds two for $23.90.
Focaccia Margherita - $19.90
Whole Roman-style tray - tomato, mozzarella, basil. The family-movie-night hero.
Zuppa di Mare - $37.90
Shrimp, mussels, clams and calamari in tomato broth. Restaurant-night flavor at home.
Sarasota takeout - FAQ
Do you offer delivery in Sarasota?
Individual meals are pickup only - that's how we keep food hot and prices honest. For groups of 10+, our catering delivers hot across Sarasota and Bradenton for a $50 flat fee.
How fast is pickup?
About 25 minutes from order to handoff, cooked fresh when you order. We call you the moment it's ready.
Can I order ahead for later today?
Yes - add a note with your preferred pickup time at checkout, or call (941) 259-1911 and we'll time it to the minute.
Is there parking for quick pickup?
Free lot right at the door at 3105 N Tamiami Trl - in and out in under a minute.
Do you have gluten-free or vegetarian takeout?
Yes - gluten-free pasta on request, plus a full vegetarian lineup: eggplant parmigiana, gnocchi sorrentina, focaccia marinara, salads and more.