Italian Restaurant Near Siesta Key FL — My Mamma

Italian Restaurant Near · Siesta Key

Italian Pasta & Focaccia — 10 Minutes from Siesta Key

Skip the beach-tourist menu. Real Southern Italian food, family-owned, made fresh. Pick up on your way back from the sand — ready in 25 minutes.

Why Siesta Key visitors come to My Mamma

A real Italian kitchen — not a beach-bar menu.

10 min from Siesta Beach

3105 N Tamiami Trl — straight up US-41 from the bridge. Free parking. Open 4-9 PM Mon-Sat, 12-9 Sun.

Pickup ready in 25 min

Order online, swing by on your way back from the beach. Hot pasta, fresh focaccia, antipasti. No delivery fees, no surge pricing.

Handmade by an Italian chef

Riccardo trained in Salerno for 6 years. The pasta is extruded fresh, the focaccia rises overnight, the ragù simmers all morning. Not a chain. Not a tourist trap.

Why locals + tourists choose us over Siesta Village

What you get when you skip the boardwalk.

Family-friendly dine-in

Plenty of space, high chairs, kid pasta portions. Casual but cared-for — like eating at an Italian grandmother’s house. Most parties of 4-6 are seated in 10 min walk-in on weeknights.

Beach picnic to-go boxes

Cold antipasti, sandwiches on our fresh focaccia, caprese salads, cannoli — packed to travel. Perfect for sunset at Siesta or Crescent Beach.

Vacation rental delivery? Use catering.

Renting a beach house with the family? Order our catering package — meatballs, pasta, focaccia, salad for 10-30 people. Delivered to your Siesta Key rental ($50 flat).

Popular for: family reunions in Siesta Key beach rentals, AirBnB private chef alternative.

Gluten-free, vegan, kid-friendly

Gluten-free pasta on request. Full vegetarian menu (eggplant parmigiana, pasta pomodoro, focaccia marinara, antipasti). Kid pasta portions $9.

Most-loved pickup picks for Siesta Key visitors

Paccheri alla Contadina — $23.90

Our signature. Handmade rigatoni-style paccheri with slow-cooked Italian sausage & tomato ragù. Travels well, reheats perfectly back at the rental.

Focaccia Margherita — $14.90

Roman-style focaccia from Nonna Maria’s recipe. Tomato, fresh mozzarella, basil, olive oil. Whole baking tray, feeds 4-6 to share.

Lasagne al Forno — $22.90

Layers of fresh pasta, slow ragù, béchamel, parmigiano. Bakes again at 350°F for 15 min if you want it bubbling at the rental.

Visiting from Siesta Key — FAQ

How long does pickup take from Siesta Key?

Drive: 10-15 min depending on Tamiami traffic. Order: 25-30 min cook time from when you place it. Tip: order while you’re packing up the beach, swing by on your way back.

Do you have a dress code?

None. Beach attire is fine — flip-flops welcome. We’re casual, family-style. Just leave the sand at the door 😉

Can you deliver to my Siesta Key vacation rental?

For catering orders (10+ guests, $240+ minimum) yes — $50 flat delivery to any Siesta Key ZIP. For à la carte meals, pickup only (no delivery for single orders).

Do you take reservations?

Yes — through OpenTable from our website, or just walk in. Walk-ins are seated quickly Mon-Thu. Fri-Sat reservations recommended.

Where do I park?

Free parking lot at 3105 N Tamiami Trl — plenty of space, no meter, no time limit.

Real Italian, 10 minutes from the beach.

Order online for pickup, walk in to dine, or call us about a vacation-rental catering drop.

Product has been added

No products in the cart.

Explore Food Items